Closes #98.
comix.to began answering plain-TLS fetches with a Cloudflare JavaScript
challenge on 2026-08-12, so every poll got a 403 interstitial. Its cover host
`static.comix.to` is gated the same way. comix therefore joins kagane and
novelfull as a browser-backed Site.
## What changed
- **Registry** (`internal/latest/sites.go`): comix gains a `Browser` entry —
`comixRead`, `Done: body != "" && !isInterstitial(body)`, `Fallback: false`.
Skip-when-no-browser falls out of the existing routing; no site-string compare
was added anywhere.
- **Read shape** (`internal/latest/browser.go`): an in-tab `fetch()` of the
Series URL, not a DOM render. comix is an SPA — rendering it costs ~65
requests for the same server-rendered HTML one fetch returns (24.5 KB,
~480 ms measured). `comixSeriesPageURL` pins scheme + host + `/title/<slug>`
and rebuilds the address, so a client-supplied `series_url` cannot aim the
browser anywhere else.
- **Cover bytes**: `comixImageURLRe` pins `https://static.comix.to/<path>.<ext>`;
`BrowserFetcher.Image` now gates on `browserOnlyCoverURL` rather than a
kagane-only regex, so both Sites' image URLs route through the one path.
Bytes come from direct navigation, not a page-context fetch — comix's Series
page sets `cross-origin-embedder-policy: require-corp`, which fails one.
- **Parsers and stored Series identity: untouched.** The in-tab body is the same
server-rendered HTML the existing fixtures were cut from.
## Verification
- `go test ./...` green (needs Docker).
- New seam tests: comix routes to the browser when one is configured, and is
not fetched at all when none is (`TestComixUsesBrowserFetcher`,
`TestComixSkippedWhenNoBrowserFetcher`); URL-pin and cover-gate table tests.
- Live proof against the real browser unit, `TestSmokeComix` (env-gated):
page 24793 bytes in one in-tab fetch, chapter 53, cover accepted by the pin,
26862 bytes of `image/jpg` retrieved.
- Two-axis review run; findings were stale comments on `BrowserFetcher`, `Get`
and the `Fallback` field, fixed in f000cc7.
Docs updated: root `AGENTS.md` (constraint + smoke command, including the note
that this dev machine's ISP DNS-hijacks `comix.to`), `backend/AGENTS.md`
(poller, cover pipeline, `BROWSER_WS_URL`), `REDEPLOY.md` §8 degrade note.
Reviewed-on: #105
Co-authored-by: Sulthan Zaki <sultankiki05@gmail.com>
Co-committed-by: Sulthan Zaki <sultankiki05@gmail.com>
This commit was merged in pull request #105.
This commit is contained in:
@@ -19,9 +19,9 @@ Userscript targets **Violentmonkey**, so `GM_*` APIs available, but stay GM-free
|
||||
- Every site is its **own origin with its own `localStorage`** — a shared remote store is the only way to unify bookmarks. Cloud sync required, not optional.
|
||||
- Userscript run in **isolated world**, so embedded API token safe from site's JS.
|
||||
- Cloudflare's block on manga sites is **per-zone configuration plus request fingerprint, not IP reputation — and not reliably reproducible.** Verified 2026-07-26: plain `curl` from both CGNAT dev machine *and* deployed VPS got clean 200s with real HTML on both asurascans.com and demonicscans.org (homepage, series, chapter pages) — no interactive Turnstile challenge from either IP at test time. Contradicts earlier untested assumption CGNAT dev IP blocked; wasn't, at least this date. Treat "does curl work right now" as live, time-varying fact to re-check, not fixed property of machine — a Site can turn its protection on overnight, which is exactly what comix.to did on 2026-08-12. An earlier version of this line blamed "Cloudflare's bot scoring"; that was wrong. The 1-99 bot score is Enterprise Bot Management only and does not exist for a free-plan zone, and no per-IP request rate is documented as an input to challenge issuance — `docs/research/cloudflare-bot-scoring-and-poll-cadence.md`. Backend fetcher still needs graceful-degrade path for when challenged, and adapters should be **verified against live pages** (Playwright MCP, on-device devtools, direct probe) before finalizing, not assumed from single earlier test.
|
||||
- **kagane.to and novelfull.com are the exception to the above** — both sit behind a Cloudflare JavaScript challenge no TLS fingerprint clears, so the backend polls them over CDP (`BROWSER_WS_URL`). When that's unset, kagane is skipped entirely (a plain fetch would only retrieve a challenge page) while novelfull pages are still attempted over plain TLS — its challenge is a live time-varying fact and its cover bytes never need the browser. The four other sites poll fine over plain TLS.
|
||||
- **kagane.to, comix.to and novelfull.com are the exception to the above** — all three sit behind a Cloudflare JavaScript challenge no TLS fingerprint clears, so the backend polls them over CDP (`BROWSER_WS_URL`). When that's unset, kagane and comix are skipped entirely (a plain fetch would only retrieve a challenge page) while novelfull pages are still attempted over plain TLS — its challenge is a live time-varying fact and its cover bytes never need the browser. comix turned hostile on 2026-08-12 (#98): its cover host `static.comix.to` is gated too, so its cover bytes go through the browser as well, and its page is read as an in-tab `fetch()` of the series URL rather than a rendered DOM — comix is an SPA, and rendering costs ~65 requests for the same server-rendered HTML one fetch returns. The three other sites poll fine over plain TLS.
|
||||
- **The CDP browser must look like a real browser, and stock headless images don't.** Measured 2026-08-08 against kagane.to, all from the same IP: `chromedp/headless-shell:stable` never cleared the challenge in 90s (`navigator.webdriver` true, empty plugin list, Chromium-branded client hints — suppressing `webdriver` alone changed nothing); `zenika/alpine-chrome` ships Chrome 124, refused outright; real Chrome with the default `--headless=new` UA never cleared, because the UA says `HeadlessChrome`; real Chrome with a stock UA **and** a non-UTC clock zone cleared in ~4s. Hence `chrome/` — a Debian image with `google-chrome-stable`, a version-derived UA, and `TZ`/`BROWSER_TZ`. Chrome reads the zone *name* through ICU from `/etc/localtime`'s symlink target, ignoring the file's contents, so mounting the host's `/etc/localtime` does **not** work; `/etc/timezone` is mounted instead.
|
||||
- **The browser is not in the API stack and must not be put back.** It's its own compose unit (`chrome/docker-compose.yml`) on a second machine, reached over the tailnet — it held 471 MiB on a 1974 MiB swapless VPS, and a residential egress avoids the cloud-hosting-IP signature Bot Fight Mode documentedly challenges (ADR-0006; not a better "score" — free-plan zones have no score). Consequences that constrain code: `BROWSER_WS_URL` must be a tailnet **IP** (a MagicDNS name 500s at `/json/version`, same trap as the old Docker service name); the CDP port binds to the tailnet address only, since CDP authenticates nothing and that host has a real LAN; and the browser is on-demand (ADR-0005), so an unreachable or asleep one must degrade exactly as an unset `BROWSER_WS_URL` — plain-TLS libraries unaffected, kagane/novelfull logged and skipped, stored covers still served. Never add `chromedp.NoModifyURL`: discovery per fetch is what makes a restarted Chrome invisible.
|
||||
- **The browser is not in the API stack and must not be put back.** It's its own compose unit (`chrome/docker-compose.yml`) on a second machine, reached over the tailnet — it held 471 MiB on a 1974 MiB swapless VPS, and a residential egress avoids the cloud-hosting-IP signature Bot Fight Mode documentedly challenges (ADR-0006; not a better "score" — free-plan zones have no score). Consequences that constrain code: `BROWSER_WS_URL` must be a tailnet **IP** (a MagicDNS name 500s at `/json/version`, same trap as the old Docker service name); the CDP port binds to the tailnet address only, since CDP authenticates nothing and that host has a real LAN; and the browser is on-demand (ADR-0005), so an unreachable or asleep one must degrade exactly as an unset `BROWSER_WS_URL` — plain-TLS libraries unaffected, kagane/comix logged and skipped, stored covers still served. Never add `chromedp.NoModifyURL`: discovery per fetch is what makes a restarted Chrome invisible.
|
||||
- **UTC is the tell, not a country mismatch.** A UTC clock is the datacenter default, and the challenge refuses it; any real zone clears. Measured 2026-08-08, identical container, one Indonesian egress IP: UTC never cleared in 60s (twice), while `Asia/Jakarta` **and** `America/New_York` both cleared in 4s. An earlier note here claimed the zone had to match the egress IP's country — that was wrong, inferred from the host clock (`Asia/Bangkok`) rather than the measured egress. A second earlier claim, that Cloudflare "scores" a UTC clock, was also wrong: the measurement is real but the mechanism is not documented anywhere — Cloudflare publishes no timezone signal, and free-plan zones carry no score at all. `BROWSER_TZ` therefore needs a plausible zone, not a geolocated one.
|
||||
- **A challenged page needs the tab kept open.** The interstitial takes seconds to solve and only then writes clearance into the browser's shared cookie jar. Navigate-read-close never clears anything; `BrowserFetcher.run` holds one tab and re-reads until the payload arrives.
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -45,12 +45,20 @@ Backend (`cd backend`):
|
||||
- Single test: `go test -run TestName ./...`
|
||||
- Build static binary: `CGO_ENABLED=0 go build`
|
||||
|
||||
Local stack: `docker compose up` (bookmark-api + postgres only; `postgres-data` named volume, `restart: unless-stopped`). No browser — without `BROWSER_WS_URL` the poller logs and skips kagane and novelfull. To run one: `cd chrome && BROWSER_BIND_ADDR=172.17.0.1 docker compose up -d --build`, then `BROWSER_WS_URL=ws://172.17.0.1:9222` in the root `.env` (bridge gateway, so the API container can name it by IP).
|
||||
Local stack: `docker compose up` (bookmark-api + postgres only; `postgres-data` named volume, `restart: unless-stopped`). No browser — without `BROWSER_WS_URL` the poller logs and skips kagane and comix. To run one: `cd chrome && BROWSER_BIND_ADDR=172.17.0.1 docker compose up -d --build`, then `BROWSER_WS_URL=ws://172.17.0.1:9222` in the root `.env` (bridge gateway, so the API container can name it by IP).
|
||||
|
||||
Live CDP proof (needs that browser and network, skipped otherwise):
|
||||
`SMOKE_BROWSER_WS_URL=ws://<ip>:<port> go test -run TestSmokeKagane ./internal/latest`
|
||||
— fetches a real kagane cover and chapter list. A red run means the challenge is
|
||||
`SMOKE_BROWSER_WS_URL=ws://<ip>:<port> go test -run 'TestSmokeKagane|TestSmokeComix' ./internal/latest`
|
||||
— fetches a real kagane and comix cover and chapter list. A red run means the challenge is
|
||||
not clearing from this IP, which is a live fact to re-check, not necessarily a defect.
|
||||
A red `TestSmokeComix` reporting `ERR_CERT_COMMON_NAME_INVALID` is not the
|
||||
challenge: it means the resolver the browser container uses hijacks `comix.to`.
|
||||
Observed 2026-08-16 on one Indonesian ISP, which CNAMEs it to a block page
|
||||
(`aduankonten.id`). Check with `docker exec <browser> getent hosts comix.to`,
|
||||
and if it is hijacked, run the container with
|
||||
`--add-host comix.to:<ip> --add-host static.comix.to:<ip>` from a DoH lookup
|
||||
(`curl -H 'accept: application/dns-json' 'https://1.1.1.1/dns-query?name=comix.to&type=A'`).
|
||||
Machine-local, so don't put those hosts in `chrome/docker-compose.yml`.
|
||||
|
||||
Smoke test: `curl` endpoints with `Authorization: Bearer <token>`; confirm `OPTIONS` preflight return CORS headers and `/healthz` return 200.
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user